RoguedexPart 2 (May 2024) · #9 of 13 in that tierWatch the moment (0:25:42)
Barony
- Developed by
- Turning Wheel LLC
- Published by
- Turning Wheel LLC
$19.99
Barony is the premier first-person roguelike with cooperative play! Adventure alone, or gather a party with iconic and unusual RPG classes to face off against the brutal dungeons. Test your resourcefulness, wits, and friendships, on your quest to lift the evil lich's curse!
Consensus
C70/100
Steam players90.7% positiveVery Positive18,198 reviews
Metacritic ↗Users: 7.5/10
VG Insights estimate ↗≈914K copies · ≈$10.5M gross
What creators say
Ranked May 2024 · #40 of 48 in that tierListen to the episode
Scored 6.38/10 · tier derived from the score
Ranked Jan 2025 · #3 of 11 in that tierListen to the episode
What players say
A first-person, voxel-style dungeon-crawling roguelike from Turning Wheel with 1-4 player co-op, inspired by NetHack, Ultima Underworld and Hexen-era RPGs.
Barony is well loved by players: Steam shows Very Positive (about 90.7% of roughly 18,200 reviews) and many long-time players with hundreds of hours call it a genre standout, especially in co-op. Critic coverage is thin; OpenCritic lists only two mid-tier critic reviews (7/10 and 7.1/10, averaging 7.05, both for the Switch port) and Metacritic has no Metascore, only a small user score of 7.5 from 45 ratings. The game is still being developed a decade after launch (new DLC and a large systems overhaul), and the most recent wave of negative Steam reviews is largely about that overhaul, not the original design. Common complaints are steep, sometimes unfair difficulty (especially solo), long runs with no meta-progression, and races and classes sold as paid DLC.
Players love
- Co-op is the main draw: up to 4 players (online, LAN, split screen), and the party dynamic and class mix is what the game is balanced around
- Deep, interlocking NetHack-style systems (item identification, cursed gear, alchemy, skills, magic, traps) that reward accumulated knowledge across runs
- High replayability from many classes, races, gear and spells, plus Steam Workshop mods and adjustable difficulty/assist options
- Charming retro voxel look, humor (cream pies, chat callouts, RPG-Maker-style sound effects) and a nostalgic Hexen/Heretic feel
- Runs on modest hardware, has good controller support and remapping, is DRM-free/open source and runs on Linux
- Responsive developers: one reviewer says a dev personally helped fix a startup problem, and content updates have continued for about a decade
- Frequent sales make it cheap; many call the base price a good value
Common complaints
- Brutal early game: instakill boulder traps, swarms of rats and other deaths before players understand what hit them; a steep learning curve and tutorial issues
- Best enjoyed in co-op; several reviewers say solo play is very hard and some classes seem designed only for parties
- Base game feels stripped: one playable race and about 13 classes, while 13 races and 8 more classes cost extra in DLC (roughly $60 total in one reviewer's math)
- Runs are long (multi-hour) and a late death wastes it; no pausing to take a break in multiplayer and hunger keeps ticking
- Melee combat is described by some as flat/clunky and loot as underwhelming in early floors, with repetitive locales
- Multiplayer desync/lag and crashes at startup or on Steam Deck/Windows are reported by some players
- The 2025-26 systems overhaul is heavily criticised by veteran players as slower and less rewarding
Can feel tedious
- Constant defensive play: peeking corners, listening for music and chatter, watching the ceiling for boulder traps
- Item identification: the newer Lore skill makes players wait (reportedly minutes) to identify items, and players still have to pick everything up
- Being pressured by the Minotaur timer to move faster than a careful style would like
- Long, unpausable multiplayer sessions where one mistake can erase hours of progress
- Grindy magic progression in the new three-school system, with reaching max in all schools called nearly impossible
- Feeling of needing to min-max everything just to survive, and deaths from things you cannot know without prior knowledge
What's unique
- One of very few true first-person 3D roguelikes, and with cooperative play without forced PvP; the developer themselves said they rarely see similar games
- Combines NetHack-like cryptic item knowledge and permadeath with real-time first-person Ultima Underworld-style dungeon crawling
- Proximity-style chat/voice and callouts, enemy chatter and combat music act as gameplay information cues
- Open source, DRM free, Linux support, with Steam Workshop mods such as hardcore overhauls
- Race and class combinations (including DLC races like salamander or scion with new magic schools) change the playstyle significantly
Players want
- Add meta-progression or unlocks so long runs leave something behind; several reviewers call it an arcade score-chaser with no rewards for dying late
- Make classes/races unlockable in-game or reduce DLC gating of core content; players also dislike having to beat the game with each race to mix DLC races with classes
- Smooth the early game and tutorial, and telegraph hidden traps and instakill threats more fairly
- Give players options to keep the pre-overhaul mechanics (lore/identify, swimming, magic progression) rather than telling them to roll back versions
- Deepen and polish melee combat and skill variety; some say classes differ only by starting kit
- Improve multiplayer stability and add official language support (e.g. Spanish, Russian, Portuguese)
Summarised from Steam reviews and community discussion.
Steam tags
Dungeon CrawlerAction RoguelikeOnline Co-OpFantasyRogue-likeFirst-PersonCo-opLocal Co-OpCo-op CampaignImmersive Sim
Similar games
More runs with shared subgenres and Steam tags.
Tier list Part 2 (2024)
Barony is a first-person, classic dungeon-crawler roguelike with many drastically different classes and a huge amount of content. He finds it deep and potentially great, especially in multiplayer, but very punishing, slow, repetitive early on and confusing for newcomers. He sees why fans love it and says it could be S for them, but it did not click for him personally. He leans to a very high B, possibly A.
Liked
Disliked